Buy the Callaway Supersoft for the softest feel, the lowest compression and the straightest flight. Buy the Titleist TruFeel for Titleist quality control, a superb soft putter feel, and a name every one of your buddies already trusts. Both are among the best-selling soft value balls in golf, and for good reason — the right one comes down to a few small differences.
What they share
These two have far more in common than not. Both are soft, low-compression balls wrapped in an ionomer cover, built to feel pleasant, launch easily and fly forgivingly for a moderate swing. Both are low-spin, so neither will check and stop on a firm green from a full wedge — greenside bite is the thing you trade away for this much ease, and for the golfer buying either ball that is the right trade. Neither is a distance leader, either; they are feel-and-forgiveness balls, not bombers, and their carry off the tee is similar. And both are value-priced, sold widely by the dozen, from major brands you already know. If you are choosing between them, you are choosing between two genuinely good soft balls — there is no wrong answer, only a better-fitting one, which is exactly why this comparison comes down to the details rather than a winner and a loser.
Where they differ
The Supersoft leans harder into softness and straightness. It is one of the lowest-compression balls on the market, so it is easier to compress at slower swing speeds and feels the softer of the two overall, and it is consistently one of the straighter-flying value balls — a real help if your miss is a slice. It also comes in a huge range of colors if you want a high-visibility ball, which the TruFeel does not match. The TruFeel's edge is a different one. It brings Titleist's quality control, so every ball is the same box to box and season to season, and it is famous for a very soft, quiet feel off the putter that a lot of players rate as the best part of the ball. It is reliably on the shelf everywhere, every week, and it carries the Titleist name — which, fairly or not, matters to plenty of golfers standing on the first tee. In short: the Supersoft is softer, straighter and more colorful; the TruFeel is more consistent, sweeter off the putter, and more of a known quantity you can reorder anywhere.
Which one for you
- Choose the Callaway Supersoft if you swing on the slower side, want the very softest feel, or fight a slice — its ultra-low compression and straight flight are built for exactly that, and the color options are a bonus. Read the full Callaway Supersoft review.
- Choose the Titleist TruFeel if you value box-to-box consistency, a soft putter feel above all, and a trusted brand you can reorder anywhere, any week. Read the full Titleist TruFeel review.
Either way you are spending where it matters — a soft, forgiving value ball your game can actually use, instead of a premium ball you cannot. This matchup is soft-ball-versus-soft-ball; if you want to weigh the Supersoft against a slightly firmer, longer rival instead, see our Callaway Supersoft vs Srixon Soft Feel comparison, or the full best soft golf balls ranking both of these appear in.
